๐Ÿ” Core Updates: ChatGPT Search results are fresher than Google's and AI Overview controversies continue [11 Nov]


SEO tips and updates from Mark Williams-Cookโ€‹
Search with Candour hosted by Jack Chambers-Wardโ€‹

SEO updates you need to know


๐Ÿ”

โ€‹ChatGPT Search performs better than Google for time-sensitive queries. However, ChatGPT Search performed badly for most local search queries and still lacks many of the visual features of the established search engines.

๐Ÿ’ฌ

โ€‹Conversational search is being tested in the Google app. This interface seems to be Google's reaction to ChatGPT's similar UI. Is this what people meant when they said "voice search is the future" every year for the last 10 years?

โ“

โ€‹OpenAI execs answer questions about ChatGPT Search on Reddit. They gave a few insights into the strengths of ChatGPT Search, such as long complex queries, as well as future plans for improving the new search engine.

๐Ÿ“‘

โ€‹AI appears in the People Also Ask feature. Many PAA answers have been included as featured snippets in the past so this appears to be an evolution into a relationship between PAA and AI Overviews.

๐Ÿ”—

โ€‹AI Overviews are testing blue hyperlinks in the body text. These are additional to the citation links at the end of each sentence and appear to link to sites that are not directly cited in the 'Learn more' sidebar.

๐Ÿ›

โ€‹A new Chrome feature allows you to debug CLS in directly your browser. This addition to Chrome version 132 shows you the direct results and elements affected by a page's cumulative layout shift without using a secondary tool.

๐Ÿ“

โ€‹Google is testing a 'highlight' button for AI Overviews. This allows users to select text within an AI Overview and trigger a second search using the highlighted text. This second search opens another AI Overview in a sidebar.

๐Ÿ“ฐ

โ€‹Publishers continue to express frustration about AI Overviews. This relates to Google using and summarising content in AIOs without a licensing agreement while OpenAI offers licensing agreements and revenue share.

๐Ÿ–ผ๏ธ

โ€‹AI Overviews use images without citation or credit to the creators. In this example, the AIO shows a photo pulled from one of the top ranking results but doesn't credit or cite it in the AI Overview itself.

๐Ÿ“ˆ

โ€‹22% of sites affected by 2023's HCU have seen 20%+ traffic recovery. While this is nowhere close to a "full recovery", these increases appear to occur after the August 2024 core update.

๐Ÿšข

โ€‹Google proposes 'richer' shipping data schema. This includes a new schema type, ShippingService, that groups shipping options such as shipping locations, delivery cost and delivery speed.

Our sponsor: AlsoAsked

Understanding users beyond 'keywords' with live data and intent clustering by Google

AlsoAsked allows you to quickly mine live "People Also Ask" data, the freshest source of consumer intent data, for understanding what users are searching about beyond 'keywords' and what you should be writing about.

Get 90 searches per month with no account creation, for free.

Search with Candour podcast

Critical thinking skills for SEO

Season 3: Episode 45

Jack Chambers-Ward is joined by SEO veteran Noah Learner for an in-depth discussion on the importance of critical thinking in SEO.

Noah and Jack champion the structured, evidence-based approach to decision-making as well as discussing the challenges and pitfalls of problem-solving, and the essential skills needed to excel in SEO.

Noah also brings real examples from over 20 years of experience, such as the transition from UA to GA4 at Sterling Sky, building data pipelines and even how to communicate important data to clients.

This week's solicited SEO tips:

Sitebulb now parses tables for your 'old fashioned' sites

If ever you build any kind of crawler, you'll find out just how much of the web is 'broken'. Fortunately, our friends at Sitebulb are helping us account for these quirks with some new crawling options โฌ‡
โ€‹
Some websites in 2024, still use tables for layouts (rather than data), and historically Sitebulb would not parse HTML inside tables.
โ€‹
As of version 8.6 there is now an option called "Parse tables" (pictured below) which will allow for these... "old fashioned" designs to be parsed correctly.
โ€‹
Fun note: I believe Ryan Jones is going through the "broken internet" pain currently with his new SERPrecon tool! ๐Ÿ˜ค

Think about how you do SEO, not why

In most cases*, SEO should be ~how~ you do things, rather than ~why~ you do them. I keep thinking about this data from Tom Capper I showed at SERPConf which shows that sites most adversely affected by HCU were ones with high 'SEO metrics' (links) and much lower brand authority metrics. ๐Ÿ“Š
โ€‹
๐Ÿ”— Think about it this way: How does it make sense if your site is consistently getting links from small/mid websites, but nobody is actually searching for your brand?
โ€‹
๐Ÿ“ˆ If websites were naturally linking to you, it makes sense as your online link graph grows, there should be more people knowing about you and more people searching for and talking about you.
โ€‹
๐Ÿ“‰ I used to apply similar thinking when I used to focus on link acquisition a decade ago: If a huge site links to you, it makes 'sense' that 100 smaller sites would hear about you from that source and link to you. Without that initial exposure, it looks very suspicious that 100 small, 'independent' sites all suddenly decide to link to you within a week.
โ€‹
๐ŸŽ‚ Hammering individual SEO metrics is asking for trouble. It would be like baking a cake and knowing sugar makes cakes taste nice, so deciding the "optimal" thing to do is put 5kg of sugar into your cake ๐Ÿคฎ

Three questions to ask about potential ranking factors

"Is it a ranking factor"? I have 3 simple questions that I need a "yes" answer to, if I want to start considering whether Google is doing something:
โ€‹
1๏ธโƒฃ "Does it make sense?" - How would Google use this metric? What what they use it for? What would be a "good" and "bad" signal? e.g. with GA bounce rate, it makes no sense because as a webmaster you can control your bounce rate and set it to any value you like. There are also good arguments why a high/low bounce rate might be good.
โ€‹
2๏ธโƒฃ "Does it scale?" - Can Google measure this on all websites to use in ranking? e.g. with GA bounce rate, while there are millions of pages that don't use GA tracking, there is likely enough data that Google could build a good prediction model - so ~maybe~!
โ€‹
3๏ธโƒฃ "Any evidence?" - What supports this theory? Is it mentioned in documentation? Has a Googler said they do/don't do this? Are there hints within patents? Supporting big data from SEO SaaS tools? Any experiments you can run? e.g. with GA bounce rate, Googlers have said it is not something they use in ranking, and it isn't mentioned in any patents or documentation.
โ€‹
tl;dr GA bounce rate isn't a ranking factor - but lots of things aren't, be careful what theories you buy into!

Keep an eye out for Storebot-Google

Google has a specific bot for e-commerce websites called Storebot-Google that focuses on product pages and checkout processes ๐Ÿ›
โ€‹
This crawler will try and complete your checkout process (without making a purchase) to verify data such as:
โ€‹
๐Ÿ›’ Shipping price
๐Ÿ›’ Product price
๐Ÿ›’ Shipping price Taxes
๐Ÿ›’ Online / local availability
๐Ÿ›’ Shipping time
๐Ÿ›’ Shipping countries
๐Ÿ›’ Payment methods
๐Ÿ›’ ...and more!
โ€‹
Explicit information you provide via structured data or via Merchant Centre will take precedence over what Storebot-Google discovers!

Technical audits have long-term pay off

Want to save 10% on all content investments you make on your website, forever? Thatโ€™s how to think about the value of technical SEO audits - as amplifiers of your efforts.

This means:

๐Ÿœ If youโ€™re currently not getting much traffic, an SEO audit is unlikely* to produce any immediate value. Youโ€™re amplifying very small numbers.

๐Ÿ˜ On larger sites with more traffic, there is a higher probability that youโ€™ll get some immediate payoff as solving issues and unlocking opportunities translate into more traffic.

๐Ÿ“ˆ The big win is the compounding return on improved efficiency. If your technical audit means you squeeze just 10% more out of your efforts, youโ€™re effectively getting 10% more value out of every single piece of content you write, forever ๐Ÿคฉ

*On very rare occasions there may be same huge blocker than unlocks traffic, but these situations are very rare!

Refer subscribers and earn rewards!

If you enjoy reading Core Updates, you can earn ยฃ1000's of free access to software and tools by referring your friends to sign up using your personal referral link.

Your referral link: [RH_REFLINK GOES HERE]


Here are the fantastic rewards on offer:

Refer 3 Subscribers:
Get tagged in a LinkedIn post to thank you for your support

Refer 10 Subscribers:
Get included in a Core Updates email as a supporter

Refer 25 Subscribers:
Get 1 month free subscription to Liam Fallenโ€™s MostlyMarketing Slack

Refer 50 Subscribers:
Get 1 month free AlsoAsked Lite subscription

Refer 75 Subscribers:
Get a free copy Majesticโ€™s SEO in 2024 book (20 to give)

Refer 100 Subscribers:
Get 3 months free InLinks Freelancer subscription

Refer 150 Subscribers
Get free access to Kyle McGregorโ€™s Google Analytics 4 course

Refer 200 Subscribers:
Get free access to Mark Williams-Cookโ€™s Complete SEO course

Refer 250 Subscribers:
Get 1 year free subscription to Sitebulb Pro

Refer 300 Subscribers:
Get free access to Mark Rofeโ€™s Digital PR Course

Refer 404 Subscribers:
Get 1 year free subscription to Little Warden Small team

Refer 500 Subscribers:
Get 1 year free AlsoAsked Pro subscription

Your referral link:

[RH_REFLINK GOES HERE]

Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Telegram Linkedin Email

PS: You have referred [RH_TOTREF GOES HERE] people so far

See how many referrals you have

Top Core Updates referrer leaderboard

A big thank you to our top referrers, who have signed up over 10 people to the Core Updates newsletter, go follow them!

๐Ÿฅ‡ MJ Cachรณn Yรกรฑez (LinkedIn / X)

๐Ÿฅˆ Nikki Pilkington (LinkedIn / X)

๐Ÿฅ‰ Lidia Infante (LinkedIn / X)

โ€‹

We'd love to hear from you

If you've got any thoughts about what you like, what you dislike, or what you think we should add/change to the newsletter, then hit reply!

We really do read every bit of feedback!

~ Mark and Jack

Candour, 30-34 Muspole Street, Norwich, Norfolk NR31DJ
โ€‹Unsubscribe ยท Preferencesโ€‹

Core Updates SEO Newsletter

The Core Updates newsletter is written by Mark Williams-Cook, a veteran SEO who is Digital Marketing Director at Candour, Founder of AlsoAsked and organiser of SearchNorwich. Over 40,000 SEOs follow Mark's 'Unsolicited #SEO tips' on LinkedIn, which has now been wrapped up into the Core Updates newsletter, along with an overview of weekly news and the current episode of the Search with Candour episode, hosted by Jack Chambers-Ward.

Read more from Core Updates SEO Newsletter

SEO tips and updates from Mark Williams-CookSearch with Candour hosted by Jack Chambers-Ward SEO updates you need to know ๐Ÿ“‘ Google Search Console Recommendations are now live for everyone. Recommendations are categorised as Issues, Opportunities, and Configurations. However, Recommendations will only appear if relevant to you. ๐Ÿ–ฑ๏ธ Google Chrome is collecting your site engagement metrics. These metrics contribute to features such as your 'most-visited sites' and are not used in Search. You can...

SEO tips and updates from Mark Williams-CookSearch with Candour hosted by Jack Chambers-Ward SEO updates you need to know ๐Ÿ“‘ Google has updated its site reputation abuse policy. The update states that content that is "starkly different from the main content of the site" could be considered SRA and is taking serious action. See the next story below โฌ‡๏ธ ๐Ÿšจ Manual actions for 'Site reputation abuse' have been sent out in GSC. Google has applied manual actions to directories from sites including...

SEO tips and updates from Mark Williams-CookSearch with Candour hosted by Jack Chambers-Ward SEO updates you need to know ๐Ÿ” Google's November 2024 core update has started rolling out. This update had been already confirmed at the Google Web Creator summit. However, Google has reportedly said to "not expect a recovery from HCU any time soon." ๐Ÿ›๏ธ Google Maps launches product search feature. This new feature includes real-time product availability and searching for specific products local to...